Error Analysis of Method for Calculation of Non-Contact Impact on Space Debris from Ion Thruster

<- Back to II. Mechanical Engineering & Physics Vol. 5

Cite the paper

Alpatov A.P., Fokov A.A., Khoroshylov S.V. & Savchuk A.P. (2016). Error Analysis of Method for Calculation of Non-Contact Impact on Space Debris from Ion Thruster. Mechanics, Materials Science & Engineering, Vol 5. doi:10.13140/RG.2.1.3986.1361

Authors: Alpatov A.P., Fokov A.A., Khoroshylov S.V., Savchuk A.P.

ABSTRACT. A simplified approach to determine the impact on a space-debris object (a target) from the ion thruster of a spacecraft (a shepherd), which was proposed before in the context the ion beam shepherd technology for space debris removal, was considered. This simplified approach is based on the assumption of the validity of the self-similar model of the plasma distribution in the thruster plume. A method for the calculation of the force impact using the information about the contour of the central projection of the object on a plane, which is perpendicular to the ion beam axis, was proposed within the framework of this model.  The errors of this method, including the errors caused by an inaccuracy of its realization, are analyzed.  The results of the analysis justify the admissibility of the application of the specified approach within the self-similar model of the plasma distribution. The preliminary conclusion has been made that this simplified approach can be used to control the relative motion of the shepherd – target system as well. This conclusion is based on the results of the simulation of the system motion, when the “real” value of the thruster impact is calculated by the direct integration of the elementary impacts over the target surface and the value of the same impact used in the control algorithms is determined using the information about the contour of the target. A number of factors such as the orbital motion of the system, external perturbations, and the attitude motion of the shepherd were neglected in the simplified model which was used for the simulation. These factors and errors in the interaction model are necessary to consider during a more detailed analysis of this approach. The analysis of the calculation errors presented in this paper can be used during implementation of the ion beam shepherd technology for active space debris removal.

Keywords: space debris removal, ion beam shepherd technology, spacecraft – space debris object system, contour of the central projection, simplified calculation of the impact, error analysis, simulation of the relative motion

DOI 10.13140/RG.2.1.3986.1361


[1] Bombardelli, C., Pelaez, J. Ion Beam Shepherd for Contactless Space Debris Removal // Journal of Guidance, Control and Dynamics. – 2011. – Vol. 34, #3. – Pp. 916 – 920.

[2] Bombardelli, C., Alpatov A.P., Pirozhenko, A.V., Baranov, E.Y., Osinovy, G.G., Zakrzhevskii, A.E. Project “Space shepherd” with ion beam. Ideas and problems // Space science and technology. – 2014. – V. 20, #2. – Pp. 55 – 60.

[3] Merino, M., Ahedo, E., Bombardelli, C., Urrutxua, H., Peláez, J. Ion beam shepherd satellite for space debris removal // Progress in Propulsion Physics. – 2013. – Vol. 4. – Pp. 789 – 802.

[4] Alpatov, A., Cichocki, F., Fokov, A., Khoroshylov, S., Merino, M., Zakrzhevskii, A. Algorithm for determination of force transmitted by plume of ion thruster to orbital object using photo camera // 66th International Astronautical Congress, Jerusalem, Israel. –2015. – Paper IAC-15-A6.5.5-x27732. – Pp. 1 – 9.

[5] Alpatov A., Cichocki F., Fokov A., Khoroshylov S., Merino M., Zakrzhevskii A. Determination of the force transmitted by an ion thruster plasma plume to an orbital object // Acta Astronautica.–2016.–V. 119. – Pp. 241–251

[6] Bombardelli C., Urrutxua H., Merino M., Ahedo E., Peláez J. Relative dynamics and control of an ion beam shepherd satellite // Spaceflight mechanics. – 2012. – Vol. 143. – Pp. 2145 – 2158.

[7] Merino M., Cichocki F., Ahedo E. A collisionless plasma thruster plume expansion model // Plasma Sources Science and Technology. – 2015. – Vol. 24(3),  – Pp. 1 – 12.

[8] Bombardelli C., Merino M. Ahedo E., Peláez J. Urrutxua H., Iturri-Torreay A., Herrera-Montojoy J. Ariadna call for ideas: Active removal of space debris ion beam shepherd for contactless debris removal // Technical report. – 2011. – 90 p.

[9] Alpatov A.P. Zakrzhevskii A.E. Merino M. Fokov A.A., Khoroshylov S.V. Cichocki, F. Determination of a force transmitted by a plume of an ion thruster to an orbital object // Space science and technology. – 2016. – V. 22, #1. – Pp. 52 – 63.

[10] Kravets V.V., Kravets T.V., Kharchenko A.V. Using quaternion matrices to describe the kinematics and nonlinear dynamics of an asymmetric rigid body // Int. Appl. Mech. – 2009. – 44.#2. – Pp. 223-232.

[11] Lurie A.I. Analytical Mechanics. – M. Fizmatgiz. – 1961. – 824 p.



Creative Commons Licence
Mechanics, Materials Science & Engineering Journal by Magnolithe GmbH is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Based on a work at